Sessions Courts cannot impose life imprisonment â€

Sessions Courts cannot impose life imprisonment “till natural life” or deny remission

Why in news?
In Kiran v. State of Karnataka (decided December 18, 2025), the Supreme Court held that Sessions Courts cannot impose life imprisonment “till natural life” or deny remission. Only constitutional courts—the Supreme Court and High Courts—can issue such directions, while remission powers remain with the executive under Articles 72 and 161.

Why This Matters?

Aspect	Sessions Court	Supreme Court / High Court	Executive (Articles 72 & 161)
Conviction Authority	Can convict and sentence under IPC/CrPC	Can convict and sentence	Not applicable
Life Imprisonment	Can impose, but subject to remission	Can impose and restrict remission (e.g., “till natural life”)	Can grant remission/commutation
Remission Powers	Cannot curtail statutory remission	May restrict remission in rare cases	Holds constitutional power to remit/commute sentences

Implications for Criminal Justice

Checks and Balances: Prevents trial courts from encroaching on executive powers.
Uniformity in Sentencing: Ensures that remission remains a statutory right unless curtailed by higher courts.
Safeguard for Convicts: Protects against disproportionate sentencing at the trial level.
Judicial Discipline: Reinforces that sentencing innovations must come from constitutional courts, not Sessions Courts.

This ruling is a landmark clarification in sentencing law. It balances judicial authority with executive clemency, ensuring that life imprisonment remains subject to remission unless higher courts explicitly rule otherwise.

Article 72 and Article 161
Article 72 of the Indian Constitution grants the President pardoning powers, while Article 161 provides similar powers to the Governor of a state. These provisions serve as a merciful check on judicial decisions, allowing clemency in specific cases.â€‹

Key Differences

Aspect	Article 72 (President)	Article 161 (Governor)
Scope	Union laws, court-martial, death penalty	State laws only
Death Sentence Pardon	Full pardon allowed	No full pardon; only commute/remit
Court-Martial Cases	Applicable	Not applicable

Download Pdf

Student Login