RBI Cautions Against Raising India’s 4% Inflation Target
The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has recently released a discussion paper on its monetary policy framework cautioning against raising India’s current inflation target of 4%. The RBI warns that increasing the target now could undermine the credibility of the inflation targeting framework and risk reversing the macroeconomic stability and policy gains achieved over the past decade.
Key points from the RBI’s discussion paper and related news:
- RBI’s current inflation mandate sets a Consumer Price Index (CPI) target of 4% with a tolerance band of +/- 2%, forming the flexible inflation targeting (FIT) framework adopted since 2016.
- The RBI invites public feedback on four main aspects: whether monetary policy should focus on headline or core inflation; if the 4% target remains optimal for balancing growth and stability; whether the 2-6% tolerance band needs revision or removal; and if the fixed 4% target should be replaced by a range.
- The paper highlights that raising the inflation target above 4% amid current global geopolitical and economic uncertainties could be interpreted by investors as weakening the framework, thus hurting policy credibility and investor confidence.
- Lowering the target below 4% is also cautioned against, given India’s inflation dynamics and high global food prices.
- The RBI emphasizes that ignoring food inflation by targeting only core inflation (excluding food and fuel) risks overlooking the cost of living for poorer households.
- The FIT framework has proven effective, with average inflation reducing from 6.8% pre-2016 to 4.9% since. The system has shown resilience through the pandemic and global shocks, and the RBI seeks to retain the stability it offers.
- The government, in consultation with the RBI, will make the final decision on any modifications after the review scheduled for completion by March 2026.
- The RBI has invited feedback from stakeholders by September 18, 2025.
Overall, the RBI is signaling a preference to maintain the 4% inflation target rather than raising it, to preserve its monetary policy credibility and macroeconomic stability achieved since 2016. The discussion paper is part of a mandated five-year review of this inflation framework, seeking broader input on whether any adjustments are needed. The RBI emphasizes that the current framework’s success suggests retaining the 4% target with the existing tolerance band is prudent for India’s economic context.
Risks of Raising the Inflation Target
- Raising the target now, amidst global geopolitical and economic uncertainty, might be interpreted as a dilution of the inflation targeting framework.
- It may signal weakening policy commitment, risking a loss of credibility with domestic and international investors.
- This loss of confidence could erode the policy and institutional gains, possibly destabilizing fiscal discipline and external economic stability.
- It might adversely affect foreign investment sentiment, as stable and low inflation is crucial for maintaining investment and growth.
Risks of Lowering the Inflation Target
- Lowering the inflation target below 4% is also considered potentially inappropriate.
- Given India’s structural economic characteristics, such as volatile food prices and external shocks, a lower target might not reflect realistic inflation dynamics.
- It could constrain monetary policy flexibility to respond to supply shocks and upward price pressures, especially in food and fuel.
- The RBI's assessment suggests that lowering the target may be hard to justify amid rising global food prices and inflation pressures.
Headline vs. Core Inflation in Monetary Policy:
- Headline Inflation measures the total inflation rate including all items in the consumer basket, notably food and fuel, whose prices tend to be highly volatile. It better reflects the overall cost of living for the population because it includes essential and frequently purchased items.
- Core Inflation excludes volatile food and fuel prices and is seen as a more stable measure of underlying inflation trends. It helps policymakers focus on persistent inflationary pressures rather than short-term fluctuations caused by external shocks.
In summary:
- RBI prefers to maintain the current 4% inflation target to preserve credibility and economic stability.
- The choice between headline vs. core inflation as the policy target involves weighing the volatility and welfare relevance of headline inflation against the stability and predictive value of core inflation.
- RBI is seeking stakeholder feedback on these issues to decide on the framework going forward, with a review due in March 2026.
This careful consideration highlights RBI's focus on balancing inflation control with growth stability, using a nuanced understanding of headline and core inflation indicators in monetary policy.
RBI Cautions Against Raising India’s 4% Inflation Target,FAQs?
1. According to the RBI’s discussion paper, what is the primary risk of raising India’s inflation target above 4% at this time?
A) It could lead to a rapid increase in food prices domestically.
B) It may be seen as weakening the inflation targeting framework, undermining policy credibility.
C) It would cause the RBI to lose control over interest rate adjustments.
D) It could result in a significant rise in unemployment rates.
2. Why does the RBI caution against targeting only core inflation instead of headline inflation in its monetary policy?
A) Core inflation includes volatile food and fuel prices, making it less stable.
B) Headline inflation excludes food and fuel prices, which are irrelevant to most households.
C) Ignoring food inflation risks overlooking the cost of living impacts on poorer households.
D) Core inflation is more affected by short-term external shocks than headline inflation.
Download Pdf
