Introduction: Iran at a Critical Juncture
Iran today stands at a defining crossroads in its modern history. Once envisioned as a revolutionary republic combining Islamic governance with popular sovereignty, the country is now grappling with deep internal unrest and intense external pressures. Persistent protests, economic distress, political rigidity, and regional tensions have converged to create a prolonged state of instability. Despite these challenges, Iran remains a pivotal actor in West Asian geopolitics, deeply embedded in global energy markets, security dynamics, and the evolving multipolar world order. Understanding Iran’s turmoil is therefore essential not only for regional stability but also for global strategic calculations.
 
Internal Crisis: Fault Lines Within
1. Protests and Social Unrest
Iran has witnessed recurring waves of protests over the past decade, most recently triggered by issues related to civil liberties, women’s rights, and state authority.

• Nature of protests: Unlike earlier economic protests, recent demonstrations have increasingly focused on identity, dignity, and freedom, particularly among youth and women.
• Demographic challenge: Nearly 60% of Iran’s population is under 35, creating a widening gap between societal aspirations and the ruling clerical establishment.
• State response: Heavy-handed crackdowns, internet shutdowns, and arrests have temporarily suppressed dissent but failed to address root causes.

This cycle of protest and repression has eroded public trust in institutions and intensified societal polarization.
 
2. Economic Distress
Iran’s economy is under severe strain due to a combination of structural inefficiencies and external sanctions.

• Sanctions impact: U.S.-led sanctions have sharply reduced oil exports, restricted banking access, and discouraged foreign investment.
• Inflation and unemployment: High inflation, currency depreciation, and youth unemployment have reduced living standards.
• Governance issues: Corruption, lack of transparency, and dominance of semi-state actors like the Revolutionary Guards (IRGC) have stifled private enterprise.

Economic hardship has thus become a key driver of public anger, linking material deprivation with political discontent.
 
3. Crisis of Governance
Iran’s political system suffers from institutional imbalance.

• Concentration of power: Unelected bodies such as the Supreme Leader’s office and Guardian Council wield overriding authority.
• Limited political competition: Disqualification of reformist candidates has narrowed democratic space.
• Legitimacy erosion: Declining voter turnout in recent elections reflects growing public disengagement.

The governance crisis is not merely administrative but systemic, questioning the long-term sustainability of the political model.
 
External Dimension: Iran in a Connected World
Despite sanctions and isolation narratives, Iran is far from geopolitically isolated. Instead, it is deeply enmeshed in regional and global power politics.
1. Iran in West Asian Security Architecture

• Iran plays a decisive role in Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, and Yemen, often through proxy groups.
• Its regional strategy aims at strategic depth and deterrence against adversaries, particularly Israel and the U.S.
• This activism, however, has intensified sectarian tensions and regional instability.

U.S.–Israel Axis: Sanctions, Security, and the Nuclear Issue
1. Nuclear Question

• Iran’s nuclear programme remains the most contentious issue.
• The collapse of the JCPOA (Iran Nuclear Deal) after U.S. withdrawal revived enrichment activities.
• Israel views a nuclear-capable Iran as an existential threat, while the U.S. seeks containment without direct war.

2. Sanctions as a Strategic Tool

• Sanctions aim to curb Iran’s nuclear ambitions and regional influence.
• However, they have also:
  • Hurt ordinary citizens disproportionately
  • Pushed Iran towards alternative alliances
  • Reduced Western leverage over Iranian society

The U.S.–Israel approach thus reflects a security-centric strategy, often neglecting long-term political consequences.

China–Russia: Strategic Partnerships Beyond the West
Facing Western pressure, Iran has pivoted eastward.
1. China

• Major importer of Iranian oil, often bypassing sanctions.
• Long-term strategic cooperation agreements covering infrastructure and energy.
• Alignment fits China’s Belt and Road Initiative and energy security needs.

2. Russia

• Cooperation in Syria strengthened strategic ties.
• Shared interest in countering Western dominance.
• Iran’s role has expanded in Russia’s geopolitical calculations amid tensions with NATO.

These partnerships signal Iran’s integration into a counter-Western geopolitical axis, reinforcing multipolarity.
 
India’s Stance: Strategic Autonomy and Pragmatism
India’s approach to Iran has been guided by strategic autonomy.

• Energy security: Iran was once a key oil supplier.
• Connectivity: Chabahar Port is vital for access to Afghanistan and Central Asia.
• Diplomatic balance: India maintains ties with Iran, Israel, and the U.S., navigating complex alignments.

While sanctions have constrained engagement, India continues to view Iran as a long-term strategic partner, especially in regional connectivity.
 
Why Iran Matters Globally
Iran’s importance extends beyond its borders due to:

1. Energy Security
   • Holds one of the world’s largest oil and gas reserves.
   • Stability in Iran affects global energy prices.
2. Regional Security
   • Central to conflicts in West Asia.
   • Any escalation involving Iran risks wider war.
3. Multipolar World Order
   • Iran’s resistance to Western dominance symbolizes shifting global power balances.
   • Its alliances reflect the emergence of alternative power centres.

The Way Forward

• Political reform: Expanding democratic space and restoring public trust.
• Economic restructuring: Reducing corruption, empowering private sector.
• Social reconciliation: Addressing youth and women’s aspirations.

Conclusion
Iran’s turmoil is not an isolated national crisis but a reflection of deeper tensions between authority and aspiration, ideology and pragmatism, isolation and integration. Internally, unresolved governance and economic challenges threaten long-term stability. Externally, Iran’s strategic relevance ensures that its trajectory will significantly influence regional and global order. The future of Iran will depend on its ability to reform from within and engage constructively with the world. For the international community, especially emerging powers like India, a stable and integrated Iran is not just desirable—it is indispensable for global peace, energy security, and a balanced multipolar world.
 

Download Pdf