The decline in the dignity of legislative institutions is a serious concern, as highlighted by recent statements from parliamentary leaders and observed trends in India’s legislative functioning. This decline undermines democratic processes, erodes public trust, and affects the quality of governance.
 
Signs of Decline

• Increasing disruptions, unruly behavior, and lack of decorum are being reported in legislature sessions, turning debates into quarrels rather than fostering meaningful discussion.
• The role of the presiding officers is often challenged, and their authority undermined, reducing their ability to maintain discipline and impartiality in proceedings.
• Frequent walkouts, protests, and focus on partisan interests over public welfare diminish the effectiveness of Houses as representatives of the people.

Root Causes

• A rise in the criminalization of politics; many legislators face serious criminal charges, which diminishes respect for legal norms within legislative institutions.
• Shorter parliamentary sessions and hastily passed bills restrict thorough debate and legislative scrutiny, weakening Parliament’s status and efficiency.
• Increasing polarization and instances where opposition parties disrupt rather than engage in constructive criticism, resulting in "opposition for the sake of opposition".
• The influence of party discipline and lack of individual voice among members, as well as executive and judicial overreach, have also contributed to diminishing the legislature’s independent role.

Implications

• Decline in dignity reduces public confidence in democracy, leading to decreased voter turnout and civic engagement.
• Poor legislative functioning burdens the judiciary, as insufficiently debated laws often require judicial intervention or amendments.
• Accountability and oversight over government are weakened, risking the passage of ill-considered laws and executive excess.

Suggested Measures

• Emphasizing the importance of discipline, respectful language, and meaningful debate, both inside and outside legislative chambers, is critical for restoring institutional dignity.
• Presiding officers must enforce strict codes of conduct and ensure their own independence and impartiality.
• Members and parties should prioritize public interest, uphold parliamentary values, and avoid reducing Parliament to a forum for personal or party agendas.

The concern over declining dignity is therefore rooted not only in observable trends of disorder but also in deeper structural and cultural issues. Addressing this requires a collective commitment from legislators, political parties, and constitutional authorities to revive the spirit and effectiveness of India’s legislative institutions.
 

Download Pdf